Fatal Hit-and-Run Kills Cynthia Sitterle on Kensington Ave in Buffalo, NY (December 21, 2025)

Buffalo, NY (December 22, 2025) – A 70-year-old woman was tragically killed in a hit-and-run crash Saturday evening on Kensington Avenue in Amherst, according to local authorities.

According to the New York State Police, the incident occurred around 6 p.m. on December 21 in front of 1970 Kensington Avenue. Police say Cynthia Sitterle, a Cheektowaga resident, was in the roadway when she was struck by a 2022 Jeep Compass driven by 57-year-old Jennifer Ortiz.

Ortiz fled the scene before police arrived. Cheektowaga Police later located her at her residence. After further investigation, Ortiz was arrested and charged with driving while intoxicated, leaving the scene of a fatal motor vehicle accident, and second-degree vehicular manslaughter.

Cynthia Sitterle was pronounced dead at the scene. Amherst Police continue to investigate and are asking anyone with information to call 716-689-1311.

Protect Your Rights After a Fatal Accident Today

Losing a loved one in a car accident near Buffalo—especially one involving a hit-and-run and intoxicated driver—is devastating. Families facing such losses may be entitled to seek justice and compensation. Learn more by reading about car accident laws in New York.

When searching for a “car accident near me” or reviewing a car accident report, know that time is critical. Victims’ families often benefit from legal representation to ensure evidence is preserved and their rights are fully protected after a car accident near Buffalo.

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE

This post is based on initial police statements and may be updated as more information becomes available. If you have questions following a serious accident, see these frequently asked questions in New York.

• Cynthia Sitterle was declared deceased at the crash site.
• Jennifer Ortiz faces multiple charges, including DWI and vehicular manslaughter.
• The investigation remains active; anyone with information should contact Amherst Police.

For help following a tragic crash, access accident resources in New York to better understand your next steps.

This article is intended for informational use and is not legal or medical advice. Content may be updated as new reports are released. Those affected by similar incidents are advised to consult with a qualified attorney. Read our full disclaimer.

If your family has suffered due to a car accident near Buffalo, speak with a New York personal injury lawyer immediately to begin the path to justice and recovery.